A blog by an experienced management leader sharing lessons learned. Discussion topics include collaboration, disruption, innovation, procurement, strategy, supply chain, synergy and talent, among others.
Wednesday, October 10, 2012
Friday, October 5, 2012
When Smart Can Be Really Dumb!
Sunday, September 9, 2012
USA needs a turnaround!
The World Economic Forum (WEF) is an independent international organization committed to improving the state of the world by engaging business, political, academic and other leaders of society to shape global, regional and industry agendas. Each year, this venerable, thoughtful and independent group, publishes the Global Competitiveness Report. The group essentially review a broad number of factors (111 this year), many objectively measured, to determine ability of each country (144 this year) to provide a good life for their citizens. This report is the closest thing we have to an objective ranking of national competitiveness on a global scale. I have found it to be thorough, unbiased and reflective of economic reality. You can access this years report here.
The USA has been declining since 2008 (when it was last ranked Number 1) to Number 7, this year!
The chart above shows the ten highest ranked countries in 2007 and follows their fortunes to the current report. You can see the top ten were USA, Switzerland, Denmark, Sweden, Germany, Finland, Singapore, Japan, United Kingdom and The Netherlands. A quick perusal of the chart highlights the following:
- Switzerland went from Number 2 in 2009 to Number 1 in 2010 and has stayed at the top since. Singapore which started out at number 7 has improved consistently to a current Number 2 ranking. Their stories and experience are well worth exploring and learning from, for any nation that is wondering how to improve their ranking.
- The United Kingdom, which started at Number 9 in 2007, fell off the list for three years (Number 12 in 2008, Number 13 in 2009, Number 12 in 2010), but finally remerged on the list in 2011 and is now ranked higher than they started at a current Number 8. This is a remarkable turnaround, and another worthy example to explore.
- Denmark has declined to the point where they are no longer among the top 10. This is a story worth avoiding.
- The USA is demonstrating a similar decline, though slower than that Denmark went through. The USA needs a turnaround to avoid the same fate!
What happened?
The 111 factors evaluated are grouped in three categories: Basic Requirements (Including Institutions, Infrastructure, Macroeconomic environment and Health and primary education), Efficiency Enhancers (Including Higher education and training, Goods market efficiency, Labor market efficiency, Financial market development, Technological readiness and Market size), and Innovation and sophistication factors (Business sophistication and Innovation). Of these, Efficiency enhancers account for 50% of the weighting, and is a category which the USA started in 2007 ranked Number 1, and ended being ranked Number 2. This decline is not significant enough to explain the overall slide. Innovation and Sophistication factors (which accounts for 30%) saw a slide from Number 1 to Number 7, mirroring the overall shift. This is clearly an important area contributing to the decline. Finally, in the Basic requirements category (20% of the score), while the USA started with a Number 22 ranking, it had more dramatic decline to a current 33 ranking. This is also clearly a category contributing to the decline.
I have summarized below the specific factors that demonstrated the largest declines in ranking. They are worth exploring, because they are eminently fixable and demonstrate clearly the issues of a dysfunctional government and failure to address fiscal discipline int he USA:
|
Top 10 Decliners |
2007 Rank |
2013 Rank |
Rank Change |
|
Government Budget Balance, % GDP |
97 |
140 |
-43 |
|
Soundness of Banks |
40 |
80 |
-40 |
|
General Government Debt |
102 |
136 |
-34 |
|
Total Tax Rate, % Profits |
74 |
103 |
-29 |
|
Transparency of Govt. policymaking |
28 |
56 |
-28 |
|
No. Procedure to start a business |
19 |
47 |
-28 |
|
Burden of Govt. Regulation |
50 |
76 |
-26 |
|
Cooperation in labor & Employer relations |
16 |
42 |
-26 |
|
Flexibility in wage determination |
10 |
34 |
-24 |
|
Mobile telephone subscriptions |
51 |
72 |
-21 |
Hard as it is to believe, there were 14 factors where the USA was ranked below the median country reviewed. Let me repeat that, the USA is ranked lower than half of the countries in the below listed areas:
- Imports as percentage of GDP - #142
- Government budget balance, % GDP - #140
- General government debt, % GDP - #136
- Business cost of terrorism - #124
- Gross national savings, % GDP - #114
- Total tax rate, % profits - #103
- HIV prevalence, % adult population - #92
- Business impact of HIV/AIDS - #90
- Organized crime - #87
- Business costs of crime and violence - #86
- Soundness of banks - #80
- Wastefulness of government spending - #76
- Burden of government regulation - #76
- Mobile telephone subscriptions per 100 population - #72
Clearly, the USA has been through some significant shocks to the economy. So too did many of the other participants in the top 10. Many of them have weathered the recession or financial crisis and have gotten their economies back on track. In the case of Singapore and Switzerland, they seemed to have excelled in their handling of the crisis. The UK is also an excellent example of a country that, clearly challenged, has been repairing its competitiveness. In the meantime, the USA has continued to decline.
My hope is that the American leadership will stop trying to divide the country into parties, between those for and against particular social issue, or even between those who run businesses and the people that work for them. Rather, they should take a hard look at what the WEF have laid out, one thoughtful view as to the key issues that need to be addressed. Perhaps, if those leaders can collaborate to get America growing again, many of the personal stresses and interests in blaming someone else for the problem might disappear. Otherwise, as they say in America, it does not matter where you came from, it matters where you are going. American competitiveness is not going in the right direction, it needs a turnaround!
What do you think?
Sunday, January 1, 2012
Why I Love This Time Of Year - Happy New Year 2012
"A Morning Wish" by W. R. Hunt
The sun is just rising on the morning of another day, the first day of the new year. What can I wish that this day, that this year, may bring to me?
Nothing that shall make the world of others poorer, nothing at the expense of others; but just those few things which in their coming do not stop with me but touch me rather, as they pass and gather strength:
- A few friends who understand me, and yet remain my friends.
- A work to do which has real value without which the world would feel the poorer.
- A return for such work small enough not to tax unduly anyone who pays.
- A mind unafraid to travel, even though the trail be not blazed.
- An understanding heart.
- A sight of the eternal hills and unbelting sea, and of something beautiful the individual hand has made.
- A sense of humor and the power to laugh.
- A little leisure with nothing to do.
- A few moments of quiet, silent meditation. The sense of the presence of God.
- And the patience to wait for the coming of these things, with the wisdom to know them when they come.
It's a new day, it's a new year! In the blink of an eye, we watched 2011 disappear into the distant memories, and welcomed a brand new year, 2012.
Once again, I got to wondering what it was about this change each year that makes us all behave so differently? Indeed, it's not just the one day. Starting in November and well through the middle of January each year I notice people around me, and even in myself, a kind of reflective, thoughtful, generous sense that is not there through the rest of the year (maybe for short spurts, but not as thoroughly).
Maybe it's because Thanksgiving is celebrated in late-November in the USA. While it was originally a celebration of the harvest and a time to rejoice after much hard work, it has become more broadly a special time for families and friends to get together to give thanks for the many blessings we have received. And it's always a festive occasion!
Or maybe it's because our Jewish friends celebrate Hanukkah, during which 8 days of lighting the Menorah, they give thanks and praises for miracles, wonders and salvation! Truly a blessed occasion.
Or maybe it's because on December 2nd, 2011, we watched the youthful UAE celebrate it's 40th national day with such pride and vigor. The events celebrated independence from the United Kingdom and the eventual formation of the union that is today the UAE. And, is it ever invigorating and refreshing as we had the honor of participating in the 40 days of celebration. Visionary leadership, pride in the history and culture, and a passion for redefining what it means to be a modern Arab nation were all on display. It's really inspiring to see what can be achieved in a short time as the UAE has in just a short 40 years!

Or, maybe it's still inspiring that we celebrate some 2000 years later, the birth of a baby Jesus. The exact date of his birth is no longer meaningful, but the life and death of Jesus has made such dramatic changes to the course of civilization (both good, and in cases due to perversion of his beliefs also bad). Christmas time has grown over the years to be another occasion to reflect on blessings, to spend time with friends and family to celebrate what can be achieved, to give gifts and generally to show care. It's truly a beautiful occasion that so energize the kids, whose enthusiasm has to be infectious to every adult. I have to admit each year looking forward to opening my christmas gifts.
Maybe it's just as simple as the clock and calendar change that naturally occurs as one year fades and another starts. The amazing thing is that it happens each year, and each year it brings an opportunity to wipe the slate clean on the past, and look forward hopefully to the future (the new year). New resolutions, and the belief that we can start over, achieve more, reach farther, is truly infectious and real. I know that every year on January 1, I feel like a new person.

Maybe it's the smart commercial mavens who have figured out how to market to us so that we end up buying more cards, gift wraps, candies and assorted gifts than any other time of the year. Despite the truly commercial aspects of the season, true meaning still comes out, and as a student of economics, I am still awed by the power of demand consumption as an engine for growth. So, any excuse to be generous and spend can't be all that bad if it helps drive commercial growth and economic independence around the world.
Or, maybe it's just that a guy like me needs an excuse each year to reach out to old friends to say I am sorry we have not been in touch more frequently during the year. Thank you for being a good friend and for the part you had to play in shaping my history.
Whatever it is, it does not matter where the inspiration comes from, and I think in fact it is all of the above, it's a fabulous time to pause and take a deep breath, reach out, be generous, be appreciative, be hopeful and plan for even greater successes. I know that I have been blessed with incredible experiences, wonderful friends and beautiful family. It's hard not to look at the world and be awed by the possibilities, especially when looking back at where we have come from.
Let's pledge to make 2012 the best year yet, and I hope that many years from now, we will look back and see that 2011 was the lowest point of a series of successful adventures that followed. Happy New Year!




